After several, surprising weeks on top, Harlan Coben’s mystery Fool Me Once has been knocked off the #1 spot on Netflix’s Top 10 list, and a new show has taken its place. That would be American Nightmare, a three episode True Crime doc about an alleged staged kidnapping that’s often compared to Gone Girl.
As for Fool Me Once, we have seen many Harlan Coben mysteries do well on Netflix, but this well? It racked up a ton of time as #1, and the last official numbers we have from Netflix for last week say that it had 153 million hours viewed, triple second place, The Brothers Sun, with 50 million.
This is yet another example of a Netflix show doing really well with a lot of people not really seeming to like it. The show had a good-not-great 67% on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, but just a 46% from fans, indicating they did not like how the mystery unfolded. But while as limited series, Fool Me Once will not get a second season, this performance ensures they will continue investing in many more Harlan Coben stories to come, as they already have been for years.
Elsewhere on the list we have comedian Dusty Slay, described as having a “clean-cut” routine that is not going to be one of the controversial Chapelle/Gervais-type offerings that Netflix is usually known for. Then at #4 there’s The Trust: A Game of Greed, a new reality series as Netflix continues to invest endlessly in that genre.
Loudermilk has made its Netflix debut recently and has done quite well. It’s another former USA show that Netflix has grabbed the rights to after its original debut back in 2017. Netflix has a history of making what’s old new again, just because of its reach. Just ask Suits.
I am curious if The Brothers Sun will perform well enough for season 2. I don’t think I saw it going any higher than #3 on the US list, at least, and it’s not meant to be a limited series as far as I know. I was going to watch #7, Detective Forst, a Polish murder mystery, until I saw that it was reviewing very badly. So instead I’m watching Boy Swallows Universe, an amazing Australian series with 90% critic and audience scores. I’m not done yet, but it really is excellent and I would easily recommend it to everyone.
Obviously a three episode documentary like American Nightmare is not going to last long on top, so we might see Fool Me Once up there once more. Stay turned.
Follow me on Twitter, Threads, YouTube, and Instagram.
Pick up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy.
